I’m sad about The Great American State Fair.

It’s a bust, so far.

It was supposed to be something special, the centerpiece public “expo” of America’s 250th birthday: A free, 16-day national exposition on the National Mall, with pavilions and programming from all 56 US states and territories, plus music, rides, cultural exhibits, military elements, movie screenings, flyovers, and a Ferris wheel. All of it to celebrate the people, traditions, innovations, and spirit of our beloved country.

That sounds awesome.

I mentioned to Johanna a couple of weeks back that I wanted to go, and asked if she did.

“No. Not if it’s going to be all about him.”

It seems a lot of people feel the same way. This photo was taken on the third day of The Great American State Fair:

Getty Images

What a shame.

It should have been a truly national birthday party.

A celebration of states, food traditions, crafts, music, agriculture, invention, regional pride, and public memory. But the branding, the kickoff rally, especially Trump’s speech (a few scripted paragraphs of patriotic boilerplate, the rest just “Me, me, me, me, me”), the Trump-centered monuments and MAHA programming, the atmosphere soaked in donor privilege and partisan politics, the performers withdrawing, the states opting-out, and the predictable lies about crowd-size all turned what could have been a shared civic ritual into something many Americans correctly read as a Trump spectacle, just as Johanna predicted.

Maybe it will turn around. Maybe the crowds will come. Maybe the meaning of our national holiday will shine through the MAGA dross. Maybe the president will make it less about himself, more about us.

And maybe, as the Irish say, it will rain beer.

The deepest problem isn’t Trump, though he fuels it. The real issue, and tragedy, is that too many Americans feel we don’t share the same country any more, the same culture, the same history, even. And they’re done debating the question.

The sharp edge of MAGA claims the country for themselves and themselves alone. It’s their country. Trump has liberated many of these followers into an assertion of the power to decide who is a “real American,” and who isn’t. And his administration is using the apparatus of the national government to establish that claim as law.

But it’s not their country. It’s ours. America belongs to all of us.

Recent immigrants and Mayflower descendants. Devout Christians and proud atheists, Muslims and Jews and so many more. Black and White Americans and those of all the various, glorious shades our people come in. Democrats, Republicans, Libertarians, Green voters and—yes—Socialists, the whole political spectrum. Trans people. The imprisoned. “Anchor babies.” The disabled.

You aren’t more American, or more of a “real American,” because of who you’re great-great-great granddaddy was, or how much money you’ve got, or what your politics are.

Goodness gracious, that is the whole point of the place! That is precisely what we celebrate on the Fourth of July, the world-changing promise and pledge that we made to ourselves and to all peoples for all time, the promise we still struggle to fulfill in a national journey unlike any other in human history:

“We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal.”

That audacious declaration, and the continuing work we must do to make it real, is worthy of a truly splendid celebration after 250 years.

We’ll have to do it ourselves.

And we will, in our own ways, our own towns, our own families.

And our own newsletters and websites.

So I thought The Sunday Poem can be part of that, too. Over the next three weeks (a 250th birthday deserves a season of observances), we’ll have a poem that touches on the great principles of our nation: Equality, Liberty, Indivisibility.

We have fought for each of those American ideals down through the generations; we must still fight. And perhaps a poem that reflects upon some aspect of the power of those principles can help, in a small way, to commemorate what our ancestors did to bring us this far, and inspire us to carry on the work.

We begin with equality, as the Declaration does.

“Lift Every Voice and Sing” is sometimes called the Black National Anthem. It is also a magnificent lyric set to stirring music, the words written by James Weldon Johnson and the melody by his brother J. Rosamond Johnson. Their stories and achievements are remarkable; it’s worth looking them up.

I’d only note how strong in hope these words are, hope that our country can fulfill that 250-year-old promise. As I read them, I was once again grateful for the long and terrible struggle of Black Americans, whose work in our country’s history was memorably described by historian Nikole Hannah-Jones in The 1619 Project:

“Black Americans have also been, and continue to be, foundational to the idea of American freedom. More than any other group in this country’s history, we have served, generation after generation, in an overlooked but vital role: it is we who have been the perfecters of this democracy.”

James Weldon Johnson himself describes how this song came to be.

—Terry

Lift Every Voice and Sing

by James Weldon Johnson

A group of young men in Jacksonville, Florida, arranged to celebrate Lincoln’s birthday in 1900. My brother, J. Rosamond Johnson, and I decided to write a song to be sung at the exercises. I wrote the words and he wrote the music. Our New York publisher, Edward B. Marks, made mimeographed copies for us, and the song was taught to and sung by a chorus of five hundred colored school children.
Shortly afterwards my brother and I moved away from Jacksonville to New York, and the song passed out of our minds. But the school children of Jacksonville kept singing it; they went off to other schools and sang it; they became teachers and taught it to other children. Within twenty years it was being sung over the South and in some other parts of the country. Today the song, popularly known as the Negro National Hymn, is quite generally used.
The lines of this song repay me in an elation, almost of exquisite anguish, whenever I hear them sung by Negro children.

Lift every voice and sing   

Till earth and heaven ring,

Ring with the harmonies of Liberty;

Let our rejoicing rise

High as the listening skies,

Let it resound loud as the rolling sea.

Sing a song full of the faith that the dark past has taught us,

Sing a song full of the hope that the present has brought us.   

Facing the rising sun of our new day begun,

Let us march on till victory is won.

Stony the road we trod,

Bitter the chastening rod,

Felt in the days when hope unborn had died;   

Yet with a steady beat,

Have not our weary feet

Come to the place for which our fathers sighed?

We have come over a way that with tears has been watered,

We have come, treading our path through the blood of the slaughtered,

Out from the gloomy past,   

Till now we stand at last

Where the white gleam of our bright star is cast.

God of our weary years,   

God of our silent tears,

Thou who hast brought us thus far on the way;

Thou who hast by Thy might   

Led us into the light,

Keep us forever in the path, we pray.

Lest our feet stray from the places, our God, where we met Thee,

Lest, our hearts drunk with the wine of the world, we forget Thee;

Shadowed beneath Thy hand,   

May we forever stand.   

True to our God,

True to our native land.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

martha acero4 months ago

Mr. Moran,

There are instances where words alone may not adequately convey the depth of one's emotions. However, encountering individuals such as yourself, who possess the ability to eloquently articulate the profound significance of becoming a U.S. citizen, even with a modest vocabulary, genuinely instills in me a sense of enduring hope. It is imperative that we harness this collective energy to navigate through these demanding times. Please continue to uphold your moral compass and conduct, as it illuminates our path toward a brighter future.

Avatar

Patricia A Nadolny5 months ago

Thank you for highlighting one of my favorite pieces of music. I was a church musician for many years and often played this beautiful song on Sunday mornings. But I never knew its origin story! Makes me love it all the more...

Avatar

Mary5 months ago

Thank you for alerting us to this magnificent piece of poetry and music. It’s one of the most beautiful things I’ve ever heard.

Avatar

Mary5 months ago

The African American story is the American story.

Avatar

DEM5 months ago

With Trump taking over, of course the Great American State Fair is going to be a bust. We all know the 250th birthday means nothing to Trump beyond the opportunity to grab the spotlight and make it all about himself. The Spelman College Glee Club performing Lift Every Voice and Sing is an uplifting and wonderful way to celebrate America's 250th--Thank you for that, Terry. " We hold these truths to be self evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights, that among these are life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness."

Avatar

Chrystie Munves5 months ago

Like many Americans this July 4th i am feeling very mixed emotions. Gratitude for what has come before us but dread at what we have become and the battle ahead to try to wrest the grasp that the greedy and hostile have on our government out of their hands so that we might once again be a functioning democracy. I became a journalist many years ago not just to call people out, but to do so with the goal of creating more fairness for people in every walk of life. Lift Every Voice and Sing is a beautiful anthem of hope. Thank you for giving us the space in your column to celebrate what has been right in our country and to hope for better days ahead. And oh yes..I'm with your lovely wife on not going to the "all about me" fair.

Avatar

Lynette Mason5 months ago

The Spelman College Glee Club rendition brought this poem to life. Beautiful! Thank you!

Avatar

Cynthia5 months ago

Terry - Another wonderful Sunday poem - a poem in song form. So beautiful and meaningful. I sometimes think that if I were a Black person today, I would want to be burning lots of things down, starting with Mar-a-Lago. Our Black brothers and sisters have been treated so horribly, and so much has been taken from them for so long - since 1619, as you mention - that it's a wonder they have any faith left in America. I didn't used to understand the concept of "reparations," but I do now, and I think every Black person in our country deserves reparations - and lots of them. Perhaps when kind and sane people regain control of our country, reparations might be on the table again. God bless our Black neighbors and friends. And God bless their onging strength and faith.

Avatar

Bob Hoenig5 months ago

Terry, I grew up in rural New Jersey (yes, there is such a thing) and am still here. Summers are a time of fairs here -- fire departments hold them, county 4-H fairs, etc. But his Great American State Fair is different. Had it been just what the name says, I'd be on my way to DC in a moment. But this one is just too much Trump yadda yadda. I just can't.... there's enough of it already. More than enough. But, if this fair was fair -- if it moved the argument for equality ahead in some way -- that would change my mind. As always, thanks for your stirring thoughts.

Avatar

Mary Healey5 months ago

Terry — once again your beautiful words stir our minds and souls. When I think back to when I sang in the Liberty Belles in 1976 — 13 girls dressed as settlers singing patriotic songs in the villages and small towns of Michigan — that time was so innocent. Even though the country still had the bitter aftertaste of Vietnam and the civil rights movement, we still felt it necessary to celebrate this beautiful flawed nation. Now in my early 60’s my heart hurts because we have let our decency slip away. But this song, your words and the good people of this country give me hope. And so I’ll celebrate quietly with my family while I hum all those beautiful patriotic songs written by those who believe this nation is worth holding on to and fighting for.

Avatar

Kelly5 months ago

Thank you!

Avatar

David Ramos5 months ago

The Great American State Fair ... great idea, bad execution. There was nothing "official" about it, until you start reading about state delegations, the contributors to the fair. But, you didn't hear of any organizing committees. A lady from Vermont didn't hear or read anything about Vermont sending any group to the American Fair until after the fact. She pulled together several boxes and brands of Vermont maple syrup, printed her own Vermont tees, caps and visors, traveled down to DC - all on her own dime. She expects to lose money, but she is having fun. She hasn't seen any other representatives from the surrounding states.

Great idea, bad execution.

Avatar

Roberta5 months ago

I am sitting here weeping for the beauty of the choir, for the words they sing, for our country so divided. Thank you for posting this, and for saying what we have been feeling: it's NOT MAGA's country, it's OUR COUNTRY, and frankly, I don't like giving it up to them.

Avatar

TJ5 months ago

Thank you Mr. Moran for sharing the voices of the Spelman College Glee Club. What wonderful voices. Totally agree with Johanna, smart lady.

Came across some photos of the celebration in 1976, our 200th anniversary when we all were in DC visiting with my grandparents for that celebration. A totally different world, Ford trying to heal our land from the corruption of Nixon, his subsequent resignation versus being impeached because even his own political party wasn’t backing his corruption. It’s quite ironic when you sit back and think about it. Trump could have never had the opportunity to have the chance to be in office ever again if those Republicans went ahead with the article of impeachment formally charging him with "incitement of insurrection" for his role in the siege on the Capitol on January 6th.

To be an American is to understand, We are all co-authors of this land. A grand, unfinished, messy song, Where every varied note belongs.

Avatar

KBFalls5 months ago

To be honest, I haven’t heard about the Great American State Fair. I might have tuned it out when there was a fight club set on sacred ground. It’s not about him. Don’t give him that power. You are an American and thank you Terry for reminding us. It’s our birthday too!

Avatar

Melissa Smith5 months ago

Read Jeff Tiedrich's salty Sunday entry for his "Everyone Is Entitled to My Own Opinion" Substack about the origins of the Trumpy Freedom250 vs the long-planned America250 celebrations. Freedom250 is the entity behind the pathetic State Fair fiasco.

Avatar

uRNangel4235 months ago

Thank you Terry for another wonderful article and poem to celebrate the “equality” of this country. This should be an inspiration for all to include all citizens regardless of color, creed, or religion, and continue to support our nation in overcoming all obstacles. I agreed with Johanna, this America250 celebration on the mall in Washington, DC was all about trump, shame that he made it all about himself, and not about this vast and uniquely beautiful country! I would not have attended either due the partisan politics. Enjoy your families July 4th celebration as I will be doing with mine! 🇺🇸

Avatar

Emma Ray5 months ago

Totally agree

Avatar

Kathy Koblik5 months ago

Thanks for the Sunday smiles and tears.

Avatar

Madeline Bradley5 months ago

Another wonderful Sunday Poem, thank you Terry! My feelings exactly.

Avatar

Leslye Colvin5 months ago

I appreciate Johanna’s insight. Listen to her. Thanks for honoring “Lift Every Voice and Sing”.

Avatar

Scott Hebert5 months ago

Thank you for the inspiration, Terry, and for the link to the wonderful Spelman College Glee Club performance. As your piece today indicates, it's crucial for us as individuals (and as communities) to remember the actual principles which our country was founded upon, and the continuing struggle to make those principles a reality.

Avatar

linda lucas5 months ago

I knew it would be a MAGA fest too. Must be feminine intuition! Johanna is young and wise.

Avatar

Cycledoc5 months ago(edited)

Yes to all that......but remember that along with our democracy Trump is trying to obliterate the culture and history of African Americans. Yeah Happy birthday to America but I can't celebrate anything but the Trump monster's downfall

Avatar

Sibyl White5 months ago

Blown away by the Spelman Glee Club and their director, singing from memory, Lift Every Voice and Sing. Reading the complete lyrics for the first time. A glorious Sunday morning experience that transcends the pitiful spectacle of his me me me me attempt at patriotism. I’ll be celebrating on July 3 (not the fourth due to competition from monthly market days which utilize most of the same roads and parking areas) with the WimDems (Wimberley Democrats) our annual July 4th parade. Afterward, a swim party and then a joint concert of Wimberley’s volunteer chorus and volunteer band. Sounds like nothing put on by dear leader could hope to outdo this celebration. I feel confident many other cities and states will organize celebrations, too. Let us know and your family celebrated.

Avatar

Karen Spears5 months ago

Yes, this is OUR country--it's where all of us are rooted. Our history is marked by grievous sins and beautiful virtue. We should learn from both; especially our children should learn from both. Our past and present are worth celebrating! Happy birthday, dear American family. ❤️

Avatar

Emma Ray5 months ago

So agree. Karen!