On Tuesday night in New York, there was an earthquake.

You couldn’t measure it on the old Richter Scale, but you could feel it in your bones. It felt new. It felt like a new Democratic Party was declaring itself—and it wasn’t asking permission from anyone to do so.

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani's hand-picked slate of Democratic Socialists swept the city's congressional primaries. Sitting members of Congress were turned out by insurgents half their age. And a chant went up at the victory rallies, not a name, but three letters, “DSA! DSA! DSA!”

Mayor Mamdani, all of thirty-four years old himself, stood in the middle of it, and he told the crowds that this was not the end of anything, but the beginning of something. Watching Mamdani, it felt like a generation taking the keys away from Granddad.

And I, a 66-year-old man, said to myself, “It’s about time.”

But I want to be honest with you about what I also felt, because I suspect many of you felt some version of it too.

I felt the vertigo of being overtaken.

I like to say that I am a member of what sometimes feels like the most despised community in American politics: the proud center-left.

That’s a little theatrical, but only a little. I come out of the old labor, civil-rights, patriotic left—the Hubert Humphrey tradition, if that name still means anything to anyone under sixty. I believe in unions, public purpose, service to community and nation, American pluralism, social insurance for all who need support, civil rights, American power when used wisely, and the idea that democracy is not just the process by which we vote for candidates, but a moral inheritance that we must defend.

The left I grew up loving was the left of the labor hall and the civil rights coalition; of solidarity with the migrant farm worker and the ordinary soldier; of a patriotism that constantly pushed the country into keeping its promises. It took prayer seriously and stood for the national anthem. That left was fierce in opposition to the status quo of those years, but it was rooted in the conviction that America is worth fighting for.

I believe it still is, and that is something I recognize and admire in this fast-rising movement in the Democratic Party—the Mamdani movement, you might call it. They want to make our country better, for all of us.

This movement is answering a real failure, and the failure is ours.

A generation of Americans cannot find an apartment they can afford in the cities their parents built, or a home in the towns they grew up in. The cost of an ordinary life—rent, health care, a child or more—has gone far beyond the reach of the people who do the actual work of the country now.

My political kind had decades to address this and did not. The young organizers knocking on doors in Queens did not invent the anger that fuels so much of this movement. It was already there, behind those doors and so many others, lying out in the street where we passed it by. The anger in this movement is right and proper. But there is also hope in the eyes of those door-knockers in Queens—because the young Americans driving this movement know it’s their turn now, and no old guard, no establishment, no worn-out rhetoric or musty political customs are going to stop them.

And it’s that demographic fact that many older Americans find frightening. Maybe it’s just Mamdani’s charisma and skill, they might tell themselves. Maybe it’s just the latest fad for these kids. Maybe the anger will die down.

To dismiss this movement as merely a fever, a fashion, a children's crusade, is to commit the oldest sin of a tired establishment: mistaking your own exhaustion for wisdom.

And yet.

Traveling under the banners of this movement, is something old and ugly.

A kind of permission in the air, the loosening of a taboo.

On October 7, 2023, hours after one of the most atrocious acts of terrorism in history, DSA National issued a statement saying it stood in “solidarity with Palestine,” that “today’s events are a direct result of Israel’s apartheid regime,” and that the attack “was not unprovoked,” while also saying it “unequivocally condemn[s] the killing of all civilians.”

The sequence there matters. A lot. So does the morality. The slaughter of October 7th was not an “attack” in any military or political sense of the word.

“From the river to the sea” and “globalize the intifada” are common chants in this movement. Those are phrases that contemplate and call for the elimination of Israel as a Jewish state. Given the history of the last 78 years (to say nothing of the last 3000 years), the people of Israel are not crazy to believe that those calls are not merely about political arrangements.

I know many of my friends will disagree with me on these points, and some may simply unsubscribe and move on. But before you do, let me give you a bit more of how I understand the beautiful, tormented land of Israel and Palestine.

Over the years, I’ve spent a lot of time in that region. I am not by any means an expert, just an ordinary journalist, one witness to many of the events that shaped the present moment.

I condemn the actions of Israel towards the Palestinians across decades.

The stealing of Palestinian land meant under international law for a Palestinian state. The brutalization of the Palestinian people on a daily basis. The rising racism in Israel against Palestinians. And, emphatically, Israel’s destruction of Gaza.

A few days ago, reacting to a poll which showed that for the first time in two decades, more Americans sympathize with Palestinians than Israelis, I posted this on X:

So: I believe there should be a Palestinian state—now—in accordance with UN Resolutions 242, 338, 1397.

My whole adult life I've held the same attitude about the Middle East that most Americans once held: A bedrock commitment to self-determination for peoples, in the mainstream Jeffersonian/Wilsonian tradition.

It is the principle that a distinct people has the right to freely determine their political status and pursue their own destiny in the world.

Israel and Palestine.

I am committed to this approach because I believe it is in the interests of the United States and remains squarely in the best traditions of our own Revolution and the best of our foreign policy.

The hardest freedom we have.

It’s not the freedom to speak—that one is loud and cheap and everywhere. The hardest freedom is the freedom to tell your friends when you believe they are wrong, to stay loyal to the truth instead of the team, to love a movement enough to tell it the thing it does not want to hear.

So let us watch this new movement rising in the Democratic Party with a glad heart and open eyes. Cheer what is brave in it. Name what is poisonous in it. Refuse anyone, on any side, who tells you that loving your country, or your cause, requires you to stop seeing.

That act of witness is not just the job of a journalist. It is the citizen's whole vocation, and in every generation it belongs to each and every one of us.

—Terry

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Lauri Chambers5 months ago

Thank you so much for your article. It's exciting to watch the next generation step up, although slightly scary at the same time. They give me hope, and so do you! Independent journalism has become the place for the truth, and I thank you for being a leader in the movement.

Avatar

Annabel5 months ago

This so resonated with me, here in Australia where we have a good PM and party in power but the Trump lookalikes are still braying. Selfishness and greed drive them but we live in a world of great discrepancy of those with and those without. Let us with give more to those without… doesn’t hurt us and makes a big difference.

Avatar

Dave Trotter5 months ago

This is where the lack of historical understanding really creates a myopic view of Israel, with a lack of any awareness. The modern far-left treats Israel and Benjamin Netanyahu was synonymous terms. But to put figures like Shimon Peres, and especially Yitzhak Rabin in the same boat at Bibi shows an absolute lack of political or historical awareness. Maybe it is the education system in the US, I don't know. But it does seem like American politics has purely turned into black and white.

Avatar

Cindy Dore5 months ago

I’m super excited about the outcomes in NY and I’m 71. I’m planning to vote out Bennett and Hickenlooper in Colorado in November. Show them the exit. We need new and younger people.

Avatar

Sue Hendren5 months ago

Same! I'm 71 also and am excited about the new young blood and enthusiasm. I'm also in Colorado and feel the same.

Avatar

Cindy Dore5 months ago

Let’s do this Sue!

Avatar

Carolyn Frazier5 months ago

Refreshing and well said!

Avatar

Karen Nielsen5 months ago

I’m 70 and I agree with pretty much everything you said. I’m not afraid to let younger people and the DSA have a chance. I grew up with the values of the 60’s and am happy to see the demise of corporate third way Democrats, if indeed that’s what this is. FDR and MLK Jr are my type of Democrat, and I think that’s the politics we need to get back to.

Avatar

Sibyl White5 months ago

Your analyses are helpful and I rely on them for clarification of many issues.

Avatar

David Dave) Jaspers5 months ago

Bravo! I'm 67 years old, and a lifelong Democrat. My Mom was an FDR Democrat, and she passed that on to her son. To the rise of the New Democratic Party, I say "It's about damn time!"

Avatar

LF Eason5 months ago

The US political system has devolved to a two party system: the Complicit Party (formerly the Republican Party) and the Complacent Party (formerly the Democratic Party). Both are guilty. Their guilt is either facilitating the autocratic fascism of Trump or of tolerating it. There is no legitimate debate as to the lesser evil of the two. History has proven them to be two sides of the same evil.

As a result, the Democratic Republic that was the United States of America is a nation of the past, not a nation that will celebrate its 250th birthday on July 4th.

Democratic Socialism has emerged as the sole political ideology that is willing to stand against both the complicity and complacency. It will take more than a few victories In NY, but Democratic Socialism is the political ideology that best reflects the lofty, never realized goals of our Declaration of Independence. It is the only hope I see to reclaim the honor and dignity of our nation.

Avatar

Elizabeth B5 months ago

Well-said! I'm quite progressive... maybe not a full-blown Democratic Socialist, but I recognize the need to reform the party. I do agree with your points. Accept new thoughts... but don't be afraid tell people with dangerous, unhelpful thoughts that they need to re-assess.

Avatar

Katherine Grace Bond5 months ago

I feel this so hard! I am so tired of politics that say the way to support one people is to kill another people. Thank you for so cogently naming the energy behind the Mamdani wave and also naming October 7 as an act of terrorism and Netanyahu's war a campaign of mass death. (I would call it a genocide.) I am 63 and understand the values you are speaking of. I wish there was a global energy of caring that prevailed in these times. Maybe there is, and the brutality just gets more coverage.

Avatar

Nina Donna5 months ago

My Midwest upbringing involves taking a considered look @ conflict before acting. Since the October 7th incident I have done just that. Alho' I routinely stay apprised on international news, this particular one ignited a necessity for a deep dive into available literature. I've done my evaluation, multiple readings and agree with your assessment of the situation. BENEATH the conflict, Israel's years long apartheid approach to the conflict & current destruction of Gaza are beyond the pale. As you wisely wrote: Palestine & Israel!

Avatar

D J Palacios5 months ago

Thanks for this Terry! Lots of love from HOUSTON, TX.

Avatar

Ellen Friedman5 months ago

This is the best articulation of this moment I have read in a long time. Thank you.

Avatar

IllinoisImYourBoy5 months ago

Love, love, love this piece, Terry Moran!! Truth spoken in eloquence - I admire your candor and wholeheartedly agree with you! 🕊️

Avatar

Mabel5 months ago

I’m 65 years old and no longer believe the narrative of Israel or the USA. I also believe no state has the right to exist after committing genocide and wars against humanity. Both Israel and the USA have lost those rights. Only people have the right to exist not States.