Barbara is not her real name.

We do not know her real name, and that fact belongs at the beginning of this story.

“Barbara” is a pregnant mother who sued the President of the United States, using a pseudonym. She was asking the Supreme Court to keep the promise our country made to her unborn child, and she was afraid of what her neighbors might do to her family if they knew.

Here is what we do know. She fled Honduras with her husband and three children, running from the Mara 18 gang, and has been living in New Hampshire since 2024, seeking asylum. In February 2025, she learned she was pregnant—just a few weeks after President Trump signed an executive order declaring that her baby, though born on American soil, would be no American.

As the litigation proceeded, nature took its course. Last October, the baby was born, on American soil. And that is the child whom—along with so many others—our government went all the way to the Supreme Court to unmake as an American.

On Tuesday, the Supreme Court refused to strip this child of US citizenship, and so reaffirmed the idea so plainly stated in the Fourteenth Amendment: Every child born here is one of us. The only exceptions are the ones that were established in 1866, when the Amendment was passed—children of foreign diplomats and of invading foreign military forces. The vote was 6 to 3 (though the principle of birthright citizenship under the Constitution was upheld by a vote of only 5-4.)

What struck me about about the Chief Justice John Roberts’s opinion for the Court is how quiet it is. There is no trumpet blast about the US being a nation of immigrants, no Emma Lazarus. It is all common law and the debates of 1866, Wong Kim Ark and the careful weighing of the Trump administration’s theory that only children of those immigrants who are properly “domiciled” in the US (as Trump’s executive order defines that term) are citizens if they are born here.

The Chief Justice closes his opinion for the Court by calling birthright citizenship a promise the Framers of the Fourteenth Amendment made to every child born on American soil. "We keep that promise today," he writes.

That’s it. And maybe Roberts is making a point with the modesty of his language.

For a century and more, this ruling would have been seen as totally normal—mainstream—unobjectionable to the vast majority of legal scholars, political leaders, and ordinary citizens of both parties.

Birthright citizenship was settled law in the deepest sense; settled not just in the casebooks but in the country's understanding of itself.

I thought the case should have come out 9–0. Instead, there were three dissents, tendentious and radical, and a fourth justice who grudgingly joined the result but not the constitutional principle, encouraging a MAGA Congress and president to pass a law and try again.

So times have changed. For the worse.

Ask yourself honestly: fifteen years ago, would this case have been close at all?

Then came the reaction to Barbara’s victory in the Supreme Court. Incandescent rage.

Representative Troy Nehls of Texas proposed a ten-year moratorium on all immigration, declaring: “You have to love our country. We gotta put a bedsheet—a big bedsheet—over the Statue of Liberty…She gotta go to sleep for a while. I’m not saying she’s dead. Instead of having a torch, maybe she needs a stop sign.”

Matt Walsh, far-right provocateur, publicly confessed a hatred for the justices in the majority—and all who agree with the ruling—simply because they affirm the plain meaning of the Fourteenth Amendment, accepted for generations:

Stephen Miller, the President's chief domestic policy adviser, reacted with his customary hatefulness and fascist rhetoric. He called the ruling “a deep knife-wound in the heart of the American republic,'“ and went on to show the depths of his bigotry and his own weird insecurities, screeching about the idea that a baby born here to immigrant parents “can sit on a jury when he turns 18 and sit in judgment of you, and sit in judgment of me!”

And then there was the editor of a prominent conservative publication who looked forward, offering his ideas to undo what the Court had done. He included, without irony, the forced sterilization of foreign visitors—a proposal that international law classifies, plainly, as a crime against humanity. This man remains employed. He will suffer no consequence at all.

Trump did not make these people this way.

I don't believe that. The truth is worse, and that’s the terrible lesson of this moment.

In the summer of 2016, a team of researchers offered people in reliably Republican states a small amount of money to authorize a donation to a fiercely anti-immigrant organization. Half were promised anonymity; half were told a researcher might learn of their choice and follow up with them.

Before the election, that little difference mattered enormously. It turns out that some people would take the deal—support that organization in secret—but not make that choice if there was a possibility it would come to light.

Then Trump won, and the researchers ran the experiment again. The gap had vanished. Same people. Same money. Same organization. The only thing that had changed in those few weeks was what they believed their neighbors would think of them.

For a long time, I have thought that Donald Trump’s true gift as a demagogue, a kind of genius, is that through his personality, rhetoric, and carnivorous instinct for the dark viscera of his audience, he creates a permission structure. He does not put hatred into people. Rather, he convinces millions of Americans that the shameful thing they carry (we all carry shameful things, since Eden) is not shameful—that the neighbors carry it too, that the mask was only ever a burden, that cruelty can be fun and funny and free. He grants permission—permission to become the worst version of yourself. It’s intoxicating.

And permission, when indulged for long enough, stops being permission and becomes character.

Abraham Lincoln, in the last sentence of his First Inaugural, famously appealed to "the better angels of our nature.’” With rebellion (grounded in racism) already primed and loaded and aimed, Lincoln still believed those “mystic chords of memory” would swell the chorus of union when touched.

Donald Trump's discovery is that the worse angels of our nature answer to touch as well, and faster.

But we have been here before.

The 1920s gave us the Ku Klux Klan reborn and the Golden Door of immigration slammed shut on explicitly racial lines. It felt permanent, but it was not. What was granted as permission was, eventually, revoked—and not by courts alone but by Americans who decided, one conscience at a time, to be kind to the stranger, to care for him, to invite him in. And to be ashamed again of succumbing to the temptations of racism and cruelty.

The old American ideal was never that we were exceptionally virtuous. We weren't. We have always been capable of prejudice, selfishness, cruelty, and fear. Our aspiration was different. It was that, despite our failings, we should try to become better than the worst version of ourselves. And thus establish a free and decent society.

Barbara is a citizen of the United States. The Court kept the promise. The harder promise—the one about who we are willing to be, in public, in our shared civic life—is not Court's to keep. It never was.

—Terry

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Bridget O4 months ago

If Miller is so afraid that he will be facing a jury of 18 year olds who were born of immigrant parents, maybe he should be less hateful towards them? His comments were ridiculous. I would rather have them on my jury than some Proud Boy, Oath Keeper, or Neo Nazi.

Avatar

Terry Moran4 months ago

Great point. The demonization of American immigrants is crazed. People are people, some are bad, some (most, I think) are good. The plain facts and our historical record demonstrate that the vast majority of people who immigrate to America--after making that decision, saving up or just setting out, leaving all behind them for the prospect our country has always held out to the world--those people are more industrious, more peaceable, and more patriotic than many native-born Americans. Stephen Miller is a bad American. Most immigrants become good Americans.

Avatar

Fran Yamamoto5 months ago

Terry, I appreciate your prolific writings and your truly inspiring character.

Avatar

David Ramos5 months ago

Less than a month after Pearl Harbor, in early 1942, FDR ordered the "evacuation" of all people of Japanese descent from the West Coast. The hysteria was quite pronounced. Earl Warren, Governor of California, said we needed to take care of the "Japanese problem." While it was couched as a matter of protective custody, it was far from it. They were forced to surrender all property rights, civil rights and any other rights. They had two weeks, or less, to produce themselves at pre-designated surrender points to where they would be removed to internment camps. It didn't matter if you were resident aliens, born here, part Japanese, married to a person of Japanese descent, you were required to surrender. The legal underpinning, the Alien Enemies Act. Does this sound all similar? Neighbors turned against neighbors, friends against friends. What was the news media fueled the race hatred. 1/2

Avatar

David Ramos5 months ago(edited)

Very, very, very few people stood with them. An order of Carmelite nuns from Monterrey ran an underground railroad to protect them. When federal authorities arrived at the convent doors, the Carmelite nuns told them, "I guess you're going to have to arrest us too, and send us to your prison camps too." The authorities were embarrassed enough and left empty-handed. The 14th Amendment didn't protect anyone then. When news reached Hawaii, my grandparents were resident aliens. My grandpa told their children, which included my mom, keep your heads down and always remember you are Americans, first and foremost. There is a sharp difference between intellectually understanding and when it is you on the line. 2/2

Avatar

David Ramos5 months ago

And, one more thing. When my grandparents passed their naturalization course, the Truman Administration blocked their naturalization and other Japanese. My grandpa had his opinion and suspicions but didn't speak it. The block was lifted by Ike. My grandpa's business card - one side was written in Japanese, the other side was in English. Underneath his name, "Proud American."

Avatar

Terry Moran4 months ago(edited)

Thank you for that powerful story, David; your family is one of our country's sources of witness and remembrance. So important for us now, as you point out. Truly.

I would only add that among the very, very few Americans who stood with all who were persecuted under FDR's order were three justices of the Supreme Court, in the infamous case of Fred Korematsu, arrested on a street corner in San Leandro, CA, simply for being of Japanese descent, and incarcerated in an internment camp in Topaz, Utah.

Justice Robert Jackson's famous dissent included an ominous warning that "the Court for all time has validated the principle of racial discrimination in criminal procedure and of transplanting American citizens. The principle then lies about like a loaded weapon, ready for the hand of any authority that can bring forward a plausible claim of an urgent need."

The Supreme Court did not formally repudiate the decision until 2018, thus removing at least one weapon from the hands of Trump.

Avatar

David Ramos4 months ago

Korematsu v United States stood as the second worst Supreme Court ruling of all time, second to the Dred Scott decision. It has to be pretty bad to earn that spot.

The Trump 2.0 DOJ did try to use Korematsu as means to justify the deportations. I believe it was a case from the shadow docket where SCOTUS ruled 9-0 one set of deportations had to end.

Avatar

Elwin N. (Mick) McKellar5 months ago

How lucky we are to have this chance to examine in great detail nearly all the ways a human being can demonstrate evil, stupidity, and self-aggrandizement in one slimy package. Lord Dampnut literally glows with corruption and hate. It's like watching a horror movie during a wild birthday party. You can't ignore it. It just feels wrong. We will have to get our joy elsewhere. Happy 4th!

Avatar

Christine5 months ago

Such a GREAT article! I wish every American was required to read this! Thank you, Terry.

Avatar

Dina5 months ago

I'm enjoying and really appreciating your writings. They feel historic! Years, decades, generations from now others will feel the same.

Avatar

JulieB5 months ago

Terry~ you are a gift!

Avatar

Robert Lawrence Gioia5 months ago

I think what most people are missing in this opinion by the Supreme Court is that they gave Trump more power and neutered independence within federal agencies. The Supreme Court also gave Trump a roadmap of how to get rid of Birthright Citizenship through Congress and litigation. I am truly saddened our government is looking to punish and torture it's people.

Avatar

JulieB5 months ago

Timing may be everything~ Midterms.

Just hope people vote.. no excuses.